Blue BuffaloWilderness Trail Treats Crunchy Dog Biscuits, Grain-Free and High-Protein Dog Treats Made with Natural Ingredients, Salmon Recipe 24-oz Bag

Dog has an allergy to chicken so these treats are perfect because they don't have any chicken or chicken by product. Large size treat so I have to break it apart for my pugs but they live them. Doesn't break nicely but the dogs don't care. My go to treat now.

My dogs when absolutely nuts when I opened this for the first time. The aroma caught their attention immediately. I have an older dog and a younger pit bull/terrier mix. the older dog had no problems chewing the treat. Both were begging for more. I feel better about giving these gals something healthier (since I've become aware) to eat that they absolutely love.

My pup loved these! They definately smell a bit but I will probablty get them for her again, she was really happy.

Dogs love these. Bought these when they are on sale -OR- when I need to meet the minimum for free shipping. Sometimes a couple extra bags. Dogs are happy :)

Update: We have ordered this again. I guess the only way to review *this* order is to amend the previous one which was 4 stars.Actually, this is still the same 4 stars for the same reason. There is nothing else in the shipping box, which this time arrived partially open from the Amazon tape not sealing even on the box flaps (but off to the side a bit), but the treats were in good order.These are her favorite treats, so we will continue to order them when we can't get them easily locally - which is become harder these days. But... yes, these are her favorites, and we'll still continue to order them.********************Arrived in box timely with other products. There was no additional packaging to prevent breakage. My pup won't eat crumbles or powdered bits if I try to use them on her food as a "topper". She somehow knows. But these arrived in a timely manner, intact. There was only an insignificant amount of powder in the bottom of the bag - nothing more than you'd expect for "settling". My pup knew immediately they had arrived because she came to get her treat right away. These are her favorites - with the duck flavor of the same brand which we also purchased.I like that the bag is easy to open without the rest of the bag tearing apart. You can actually zip the bag back closed quite easily for fresher keeping. This also makes it nice for the road if you're doing any traveling or just keep dog treats in the car for running errands. However, I have a cookie jar into which I empty the original bag. That works better for us. The value size bag fills the jar. She loves these treats. Her favorite ones are the duck flavor by the same brand which we also ordered to rotate. They have also been nice for traveling for the very fact that the bag is resealable.The value size bags we always find to be the best price per ounce. It's like getting a smaller bag free most of the time. Add your subscription to save an additional 5% off, and four more items for 10% off your next shipments. I always put those 6 months out knowing I can adjust that as needed so we don't end up with too many.I will say that we have bought these for years, and they were top-notch the first several years. Unfortunately, the consistency is unreliable. The bag previous to this which we picked up was burnt. She ate most of them, but by the time we got near the bottom, she really didn't want them. She'd drop them on the floor. These were also a little harder than usual, but she seemed to accept them right away.Overall, for the treats themselves and the resealable bag, I'd give them 5 stars, but for the inconsistency when they end up almost burnt sometimes, that will take them to 4 stars.

My dogs clamor over this treat. Helps to teach them good manners.

my dogs love it!

There is not much our dog won't do for these treats. They are a trusty brand and they are just the right size for our lab.